MLK Day
Happy Birthday, Martin Luther King Jr.!!
This #MLKday, I'm thinking a lot about our country's long history of oppression against the Black community, and our responsibility as Jews and simply as people to work against that oppression.
Today, you'll probably see a lot of Jewish accounts posting about MLK and his relationship with Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel. The history of Jewish influence in the civil rights movement is important history to learn about, but it's also important that we don't rest on our laurels— MLK & AJH's friendship 60 years ago does not excuse us from doing the work today.
What are you doing today and all year long?
A brief historical timeline of Black-Jewish relations in the United States
Click to read the plain text:
Antebellum
Jews in the pre-war USA tended to reflect the views of their white gentile neighbors. In the North, Jews were largely abolitionist and in the South, the same percent of Jews owned slaves as gentiles who owned slaves.
Reconstruction
After the war, the two communities began to meet in Northern urban centers as two major migration streams intersected: African Americans moving North and into cities in a decades-long flight from oppression, violence, and discrimination called the Great Migration, and East European Jews fleeing the same forces in a different setting. While relatively few Blacks and Jews interacted politically (outside of the Left), far more encountered each other in economics. In most cases, Jews had the upper hand. Because Jews were largely white, they were able to benefit from the American system that apportioned opportunity more by race than by religion.
1913 - the Leo Frank Case
Leo Frank (a Jew) was convicted of murder in 1913 on the testimony of a Black man in an anti-Semitic trial in Atlanta, and lynched two years later, it prompted the newly formed Anti-Defamation League (ADL) to proclaim its commitment to defending the rights of all. But in practice, Frank’s murder convinced many Jews that life in the United States was dangerous enough without taking on Black people’s problems as well.
WWII Era
Nazism and the war brought Black and Jewish liberals to a new recognition of the importance of civil rights and racial tolerance. At the same time, anti-Communism also led them to limit their strategies, goals, and coalitions in ways that hobbled the potential for fundamental social change. The stage was set for what many consider the “golden age” of Black-Jewish relations. In both communities, leaders worked to educate their own people on the dangers of bigotry against any other group. Such efforts succeeded widely, revealed in the disproportionate number of Jews supporting Black civil rights compared with other whites, and a rapid decline in reported anti-Semitism in the African-American community.
Civil Rights
By the late 1940s, political relations between Black and Jewish political agencies warmed as the civil rights movement gained force. The two communities had gotten to know one another through common work. Their organizations had become more desirable allies as their earlier successes brought increased membership, stronger finances, and greater political access. And they shared a set of liberal values, including bringing change within the existing system; employing moderate, non-confrontational tactics in doing so; a commitment to the centrality of individual rights rather than privileges bestowed by membership in a group; and a conviction that it was the obligation of government to foster equal opportunity liberal civil rights organizations rooted in the two communities slowly began to develop a close partnership, launching programs separately and jointly to improve conditions for racial and religious minorities.
Post-Civil Rights
After the civil rights movement, Black activists (and white leftists) had become radicalized by the failure of the liberal promise: white resistance, police violence, and the persistence of poverty and segregation suggested that liberal whites could not be trusted. And Jews constituted one of the largest and most visible segments of liberal whites. iots, violence, nationalism, and confrontational Black demands reinforced Jewish racism. Skeptical Jewish leaders backed off from earlier alliances. Many of their constituents, now in suburbs, felt less concerned with urban strife. Others became neoconservatives, arguing that liberalism had lost its way. So African Americans in turn felt betrayed by Jews, whom they believed had abandoned them, and the fight for civil rights. The Nation of Islam and its leader Louis Farrakhan advertised its antisemitism, while academics and students fought their own battles on campuses across the country. One early dimension of affirmative action particularly troubled Jews: quotas. African Americans intended quotas as a floor, designed to open and include them, but Jews, for whom quotas were historically used to exclude and limit, balked. Once the legal concept was clarified, most Jews came to support affirmative action.
"Martin Luther King knew that understanding folks who are different than you is the first step to building community with them, and thus making meaningful change in the world.
I imagine while marching on the Selma bridge and before giving his “I Have a Dream” speech in 1963, Dr. King looked around and saw his Black and Jewish siblings and witnessed powerful unity.
Let Martin Luther King’s words and actions not just inspire us, but push us to learn about the Jewish community through personal relationships and education.
Let us unite by what we have in common, not what makes us different."
"Black antisemitism is real; so is Jewish racism... But here we are, together, in the same boat, as fierce waves of hate threaten to sink our vessels in the ocean of American opportunity.
Remember that African Americans and Jews are passengers on the same ship facing the ferocious headwinds of bigotry and hatred. The author and psychoanalyst Frantz Fanon said he learned to be “responsible in my body and soul for the fate reserved for my brother,” understanding that “the antisemite is inevitably a Negrophobe.” That is a lesson we should all learn."
"Today is Dr Martin Luther King Jr’s birthday and this weekend we celebrate his memory. To my white Jewish siblings before you reference Abraham Joshua Herschel please remember this is King’s Birthday.
If you can’t help yourself and need to reference Herschel as an example of a Jewish civil rights leader please remember 2 things. The first is that was almost 60 years ago. Who would you lift up today.
The 2nd is that Herschel and King were actual friends. We can’t do the hard work of freedom and civil rights for black and brown people unless we are in relationship with people of color. Happy Birthday Dr. King your memory has truly been a blessing for all of us."
"Does the Selma march of 1965 continue to mark a moment of celebration?
Jews have long been proud of Jewish support for Dr. King and the Civil Rights movement... the Selma march serves as a point of pride and inspiration for further Jewish social activism.
On the other hand, numerous commentators have argued that relations between Blacks and Jews deteriorated starting in the late 1960s after the death of Dr. King... the photograph might be viewed not a celebration, but a moment lost in a relationship that no longer thrives.
Are we actively forging alliances with the African American community? When will African American and Asian American Jews feel fully at home in Jewish institutions? Can we put aside our pride in the efforts of Jewish civil rights workers of the 1960s and recognize how much work is left for us to do?
The right to feel pride in that photograph must be earned through our ongoing hard work."
Dr. Susannah Heschel
Daughter of Abraham Joshua Heschel
"The Challenge of the Selma Photograph"
"I strongly disagree with the statement... that more than 5.5 million Jews in America are 'lost without hope, this type of narrow sectarianism can only lead to irrational religious bigotry and serve to create a dangerous climate of separation between people of different religious persuasion."
Reverend Martin Luther King JR
"There is an evil which most of us condone and are even guilty of: indifference to evil. We remain neutral, impartial, and not easily moved by the wrongs done unto other people. Indifference to evil is more insidious than evil itself; it is more universal, more contagious, more dangerous. A silent justification, it makes possible an evil erupting as an exception becoming the rule and being in turn accepted."
Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel
Religion and Race, 1963